39 Comments
User's avatar
Ross's avatar

Mia: "Adolescents with their whole lives ahead of them. What a crime it would be to steal the unknowns that await them."

Such a perfectly modest but complete way to tie your life story in to your life's work. Keep being you, Mia.

Tom Jones's avatar

That was such a wonderful story Mia and "to be continued" of course. What a lovely wise old woman you're going to be one day!

Mia Hughes's avatar

Thank you. It wasn't easy writing something so personal.

Tom Jones's avatar

Yes I get that. I think you created a very solid foundation on which to rest any future writing about your personal journey. I don't think you could have written anything like that at any other place. It had to be there because obviously your heart is there.

You're so well loved Mia!

Mia Hughes's avatar

Exactly. It's nowhere near as polished as it would have been if I'd taken my time over it. But I had to write it while in Taiwan. It had to be finished on that balcony. And I actually think it's better for being imperfect.

Ross's avatar

Mia you are truly incredible. I struggle to read many substack essays that are too long or don't excite. This is so well written it is engaging from start to end.

Mia Hughes's avatar

Thank you for this lovely comment, Ross.

Alison Krone's avatar

I listen to you on your podcast Mia and really like your take on things. As well as your calm and considered approach. I really enjoyed finding out more about you reading this beautifully written piece. Looking forward to reading more. Thankyou.

Ute Heggen's avatar

Mia Hughes, you are a gift from God to the world. I collect the sole data in the world on the experiences of women whose husbands "transition."

Here's a clip from that foreign country.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TKdTjr6N9g&t=67s

Tildeb's avatar

Thanks for introducing me to Taiwan, a country I know nothing about. I feel now I've had a glimpse. Wonderful.

Mia Hughes's avatar

It is truly my favourite place on earth. I was actually quite anxious about how my children would handle it, but they fell completely in love with Taiwan too.

James M. Boekbinder's avatar

Great essay - interesting to know more about your history.

Sex Reality Bites's avatar

What a beautiful piece of writing. I really needed to read it tonight, thank you.🖤

Claire Light's avatar

Beautiful!

JaneSmith9941's avatar

💙💙💙 thank you so very much!

YCunnington's avatar

Thank you for this lovely essay.

Nile Dee's avatar

Read and write in Mandarin, Mia Hughes! You never cease to surprise. Love a personal story, thank you for sharing. And all the you and Stella do.

Scared_for_my_daughter's avatar

This is beautiful Mia, thank you for sharing this perspective and for your continued fight for young people who need a chance to become the person they were born to be, with time and without medical harm. ❤️

JaneSmith9941's avatar

If your trans young adult child who has begun medicalizing were to offer to exchange information with you in support of your respective positions (and you're restricted to clear science with citations to verifiable studies) what 1-3 links would you choose?

Mia Hughes's avatar

Oh, that's a tough question. For me, the HHS report that came out last year is the best science-based document out there. But it addresses minors. That's its only flaw in my mind. But the history, the philosophy, the ethics, the shoddy science, and the fraud of WPATH are all in there - explained beautifully and in meticulous detail.

I find it difficult to reach people with "the science." Because the other side has such a mountain of junk science, and unless you're able to read the studies and see why they're garbage, it's easy to be befuddled into thinking that these treatments are legit.

JaneSmith9941's avatar

Right? And idk at this moment. My kid was always very academic and science-minded. For ages he was the one who could debate better than anyone, and would pause to look up and verify facts right in the middle of it (whether his own or the other person's) and if that showed he was wrong about something he'd be quick to say, "oh, huh, my bad, I guess I had that wrong".

But over the last 2(?) years that's all gone. If you question any of what he's saying you're evil, bigoted and harmful. Or at the very least, an idiot.

But at this last meeting he asked me what I believed to be evidence on "my side". I hadn't anticipated going there so I didn't have notes ready. I'm terrible at remembering names (of studies or people), especially when put on the spot. I couldn't even think of WPATH! or what those faulty protocols are called. The only thing that came to mind quickly was the Cass Report. But I figured that was like a bad word to him, ya know? I just assumed he'd already seen a bunch of stuff "debunking" it. I didn't want to mention SEGM or GenSpec or any of these “enemies”. I ended up saying, "The Cass Report is just the tip of the iceberg…". He stopped me and asked what that was then said he'd never heard of such a thing and it was clear I had no clue what I was talking about because I can't even cite a single study and I'm obviously only being fed junk science. He then suggested we exchange our respective resources and I agreed.

No, at this point, I don't think it'll change his mind. He's going down this path way further and way harder for way longer than I ever imagined. But I still want to put our best foot forward and maybe just having those links will be a pebble. Maybe get his algorithms to alter just a bit too. Idk.

I do think the HHS report was the main one I was trying to remember. And maybe one video panel that gets Stella in front of him. The woman positively oozes kindness and empathy. And if there's something breaking down the impact of cross-sex hormones (including the initial improvements/euphoria) that DOESN'T read like click bait/doomsayer. I've got two articles and one video so far with great information and charts and citations but the presentation is a non-starter.

Mia Hughes's avatar

Let me give this some more thought. As for an academic paper, The Myth of Reliable Research is exceptional. But again, it's about the puberty suppression experiment. Most of the focus is on minors.

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0092623X.2022.2150346

Not a scientific paper but very compelling is Ritchie Herron's interview with Andrew Gold.

https://youtu.be/tk7NX7iPr9k?si=RESNjkYjmqo-weuM

The problem with the field of gender medicine is they don't do follow up. So you can't find studies that show poor outcomes because no one is tracking the outcomes.

JaneSmith9941's avatar

I find I'm always coming back to that particular interview with Ritchie. But I also think I need to keep these under an hour. Much less if possible.

I'm leaning towards The GenSpect 101 Panel

https://youtu.be/CxKFhlsUy9w?si=avLD6rlk9unsFtPC

Forrest has published some excellent stuff here on Substack (which I could never find but only today remembered the extra “r”), Soren’s latest video on YouTube is amazing, and Maia is on a roll with her extended Autism article.

JaneSmith9941's avatar

OMGsh Ritchie is so compelling, I have this interview already in both my public and private detrans playlists. Man, all these lovely humans I'm so very glad to "know" and also desperately wish there was no reason I ever would have heard of them. I'm incredibly grateful for their bravery and honesty and thoughtfulness. It's just incredible. May we make it worth it to them ❤️‍🩹

That written link is excellent too, thank you :)

JaneSmith9941's avatar

Just watched your piece on detransitioning society over on YouTube. You speak with such conviction, courage and clarity - and yet such softness and grace. I greatly appreciate your voice in this tumultuous season. I'm afraid I brace myself more during your speeches because I can almost *feel* my son bristling just because your words exist somewhere out in the world. Not that he's listening. But I believe one day he will hear it. And one day he'll take comfort that someone cares so much and so boldly. Thank you for being a stalwart example to those of us who are struggling merely to stand up at all during this battle ❤️‍🩹

JaneSmith9941's avatar

Just watched your piece on detransitioning society over on YouTube. You speak with such conviction, courage and clarity - and yet such softness and grace. I greatly appreciate your voice in this tumultuous season. I'm afraid I brace myself more during your speeches because I can almost *feel* my son bristling just because your words exist somewhere out in the world. Not that he's listening. But I believe one day he will hear it. And one day he'll take comfort that someone cares so much and so boldly. Thank you for being a stalwart example to those of us who are struggling merely to stand up at all during this battle ❤️‍🩹

Aurora Johnson's avatar

Such a beautiful essay. I love it so much. Thank you.